Copyright Jori Bolton
Communicative English class about romance and smartphone app obsession, based on short film 97%
One of my favourite films of the last ten years or so is Spike Jonze’s Her (2013). It is at once science fiction and science present, with many of its ideas about artificial intelligence and its effect on relationships already seeming quite plausible. What I feel is the strength of Her is its uncynical view of love in the digital age. A dystopia it may be, but it is neither judgemental or preachy.
I have long thought about how I could structure a clip-based class around a scene from Her but could never find the right clip. The ones already available for distribution online tend to be quite wordy and thus not really the kind I prefer to use for stimulating discussion and creativity in the ELT classroom. I had spent some hours trying to find a clip that cleverly evokes similar ideas to that of Her but without great success. Many of the short films I found were either too didactic in the delivery of their message, or of limited aesthetic interest.
Then I did one of those shot-in-the-dark Google searches that delivers exactly what you are looking for, and I fell upon this thoughfully-curated post on Quora entitled What are the best short films about social media? by Jeremy Ratzlaff. There are some really interesting films here, some dark and others more humourous – notably my favourite 97%.
97% is particularly interesting as it uses comedy and an imaginative visual style to carry its message about the limitations and manipulations of social media, but without being too “on-the-nose”, as Ratzlaff calls it. Largely dialogue-free, it tells its story with economy and a series of comic twists which I hoped to exploit in class. A cursory glance at Kieran Donaghy’s pioneering Film English website deflated me somewhat, as I realized he had already put together a really lovely class on 97%. On the bright side, he had taken a rather different approach to the one I had envisaged, so I’m sure he won’t mind if I elaborate on that here.
This class could be an extension on my class about virtual reality and particularly the trailer for the film Brainstorm used in that post. It would suit older teenagers and adults.
To engage students and elicit useful vocab for the clip analysis, put them in pairs/small groups and show them the images below, as well as the one above, and ask them to describe them (who? what? where? why? etc.). They should also compare and contrast them: what are their differences and similarities in terms of message?
[I apologize for not having artist credits for these images, please contact me if you know who owns copyright for them]
Once the students have had time to share their ideas, solicit suggestions from the whole class, noting down useful vocab for all to see.
Tell students they are going to watch a film called 97%, which is linked to the theme from the warm up. Hold a quick class discussion. Can they predict what it is going to be about?
Show students the first 1’25”, leaving the screen on pause when there is a close-up of the man’s phone and the dating app which says “We Found a 97% LoveMatch nearby!” Before showing the clip, ask the pairs/groups to focus on the following gist questions/prompts:
- Describe the man’s environment (what is he doing and where?)
- What do we learn about the man’s life?
- How do you feel about the man?
- What do you think will happen next? Why?
Watch until 3’15” and repeat the exercise:
- What do we learn about the woman he is looking for?
- How does he know that the women he sees do not have these characteristics?
- What do you think will happen next and why?
Watch until 5’30” and repeat the exercise:
- Where does he go? What happens and why?
- How do you feel about the man’s behaviour?
- What do you think he should do?
- What do you think he will do?
Watch the rest of the film:
- What happens in the end?
- What do you think the message of the film is?
- Do you think the film is successful in the way it communicates its message?
- What is your opinion on that message?
You could do one or a combination of the following tasks, or have different groups work on different projects:
- A debate/discussion about finding love on the internet age (is there such thing as a 100% lovematch? Do you think algorithms can find you a perfect partner?).
- Have students imagine and present the story from the perspective of the 97% LoveMatch. What situations and feelings could she experience?
- Have students imagine and present additional scenes for the film. What do they think could happen next?
- Have students imagine and present their ‘97% LoveMatch’. What would they look like? What kind of personality/taste/interests etc.? [discouraging any body shaming language]
- Physical characteristics (height, hair type, facial expressions etc.)
- Personalities (smiley, bubbly, serious, intellectual etc.)
- Comparatives (less than 20 metres etc.)
- Prepositions and phrasal verbs (to go out, to sit down, to stand up, to look at etc.)